5 Top Rated Toaster Ovens (2021 Reviews & Comparison Guide)

5 Top Rated Toaster Ovens (2021 Comparison Guide) explores the features and pros and cons of some of the top-rated toaster ovens. Are you tired of cooking in a large oven when you’re cooking for 1-2 people? Are you tired of having multiple appliances taking up counter space? Then a toaster oven might be your next best-loved kitchen appliance.

By reading 5 Top Rated Toaster Ovens, you will become a more informed consumer before purchasing a toaster oven. There is a table at the bottom of the post for an easy side-by-side visual comparison.

With all products, features can change, so before purchasing, be sure the features that attracted you to the product are still the same.

Black+Decker

5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens - Black and Decker

Features

5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens - Black and Decker Features
  • Color
    • Black and Silver
  • 4 Functions
    • Baking
    • Broiling
    • Toasting
    • Warmer
  • Heats Up to 450°
  • Timer – 30 Minute
  • Accessories
    • Bake Pan
    • Broil Rack
    • Crumb Tray – Removable
  • Size Capacity – Can fit 9″ pizzas, 4 slices of bread, etc.

Specifications

  • Stainless Steel
  • Product Dimensions
    • 11.18 x 15.47 x 8.3 inches
  • Weight
    • 5 lbs
  • Manufacturer: BLACK+DECKER
  • Brand: BLACK+DECKER
  • ASIN: B00GGFHH4U

Pros

  • Price Point
  • Toasts Well
  • Small Space Conducive 

Cons

  • 1 Rack Level
  • Hot to the Touch
  • No Off Switch

The TO1313SBD Toaster Oven by Black+Decker is an entry-level product. An advantage of an entry-level product is it also comes with a reasonable price tag. The disadvantage you might find is that it doesn’t come with all the bells and whistles more expensive models provide. 

The temperature of this toaster oven goes up to 450°F and has four functions – baking, broiling, toasting, and keeping food warm, making it perfect for cooking burgers, chicken, fish, vegetables, etc. Large enough to heat a 9” pizza or four slices of toast. 

There is a removable crumb tray making for easier cleaning. 

Two disadvantages are it doesn’t have all the bells and whistles of some of the more expensive models (this might be fine to you it comes down to personal preference. The other disadvantage is that it only has 1 rack position.

This oven will get hot, so be sure to have protective mitts or potholder on hand to use. 

Being small in size, if you’re cooking for 1-2 people, this model could be a good option for you. 


Hamilton Beach

5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens - Hamilton Beach

Features

  • Color
    • Stainless Steel
  • Functions
    • Bake
    • Broil
    • Toast
  • Extra-Wide Toast Slot
  • Toast Shade Selector
  • Heats Up to 450°
  • Timer -60 minute
    • Auto Shut Off
  • 2-Rack Levels
  •  Accessories
    • Baking Pan
    • Rack
    • Removable Crumb Tray
  • Size Capacity – 9″ Pizza, muffins, potato, casserole etc.

Specifications

  • Product Dimensions
    • 12.05 x 17.8 x 10.24 inches
  • Weight
    • 10.9 lbs
  • Manufacturer – Hamilton Beach
  • Brand – Hamilton Beach
  • ASIN: B0758B74DS

Pros

  • Easy cleaning
  • 2 Rack Positions
  • Toast Slot

Cons

  • Gets Hot
  • No Off Switch
  • Uneven Toasting

A nice feature that the Hamilton Beach toaster oven has is the separate toaster slots. Most toaster ovens have the function where you toast inside the oven, but this one has adjustable slots on top that allow for different thicknesses, i.e., bread, bagels.

Another nice feature is it comes with two rack positions.

The Hamilton Beach toaster oven is equipped with three functions – Bake, broil, and toast and fits a 9” pizza.


KitchenAid

5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens - KitchenAid

Features

  • Stainless Steel
  • Non-Stick
  • 9 Preset Functions + Frozen
    • Bagel
    • Bake
    • Broil
    • Cookies
    • Pizza
    • Reheat
    • Roast
    • Toast
    • Warm
  • 50% more capacity
  • Heats Up to 450°
  • Accessories
    • Baking Pan
    • Grill Rack
    • Drip and Crumb Tray
    • Metal Rack

Specifications

  • Dimensions
    • 16 x 17 x 11.3 inches
  • Weight
    • 15.9 lbs
  • Manufacturer – KitchenAid
  • Brand – KitchenAid
  • ASIN: B07T3J3B13

Pros

  • Brand Name
  • Non-Stick Interior
  • Quick Preheat

Cons

  • No Light Inside
  • Small Cooking Space
  • Snug Fit of Baking Pans

Kitchen Aid is a well-known kitchen appliance brand. This particular toaster oven is larger and heavier than some, so be aware it will take up more counter space.

It comes with nine yes nine functions and an extra one for frozen – Bake, Broil, Toast, Warm, Reheat, Bagel, Pizza, Cookies, Roast + Frozen.

The non-stick interior makes for easier cleanup.


HomeRusso

5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens-HomeRusso

Features

5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens-HomeRusso - Features
  • Color – Silver
  • Non-Stick
  • Convection Fan
  • Functions – 24
    • 16 Air Fryer Modes
    • 8 Oven Modes
  • 3 Rack Levels
  • Capacity – 15.8 Quarts – 7 lb Whole Chicken, 8 Inch Pizza, 2 lb French Fries, etc.
  • Accessories
    • Bake Rack
    • Rotisserie Fork
    • Air Fryer Baskets
    • Tray Handle
    • Fetch Tool
    • Crumb Tray
    • Baking/Drip Tray
    • Skewer Racks
    • Oven Glove

Specifications

  • Dimensions
    • 12.32 x 13.54 x 13.35 inches
  • Weight
    • 15.47 lbs
  • Manufacturer – HomeRusso
  • Brand – HomeRusso
  • ASIN: B08S7K866V
  • 2-year Warranty

Pros

  • 24 Programs
  • Air Fryer/Oven in 1
  • Accessories
  • 2-year Warranty

Cons

  • Price Point
  • Size

The Home Russo is more than a toaster oven. It also serves as an air fryer and dehydrator. Coming with 24-in-1 preset functions with 16 air fryer modes and 8 oven modes, you’ll have so many options for cooking.

The Home Russo comes with 9 accessories giving so much without going out and buying many additional products.

Having three rack levels allows you to cook different foods at the same time.

You get so many accessories with this oven without needing too much extra counter space compared with the other toaster ovens.

Be sure to measure to be sure you have enough room – don’t forget to measure height if you plan to store it on your countertop under cupboards.

For size reference, it allows the ability to cook a 7 lb. chicken.


Ninja SP101 Foodi

5 Top Rated Toaster Ovens - Ninja

Features

  • Color – Stainless Steel
  • 8 Functions
    • Air Broil
    • Air Fry
    • Air Roast
    • Bagel
    • Bake
    • Dehydrate
    • Toast
    • Keep Warm
  • Toast Shade Selector
  • Accessories
    • Air Fry Basket
    • Crumb Tray
    • Wire Rack
    • Sheet Pan
  • Capacity – Fits a 13″ Pizza, Up To 9 Slices of Toast or 6 Chicken Breasts (6–8 oz. Each).

Specifications

  • Dimensions
    • 19.72 x 7.56 x 14.96 inches
    • Flipped Up: 19. 7″ 15. 1”H x 7. 5”D
  • Weight
    • 15.72 lbs
  • Manufacturer – SharkNinja
  • ASIN: B07SCGY2H6

Pros

  • Folds Up to Clear Counter Space
  • Quick Heating

Cons

  • Hard to Clean
  • Not a lot of height
  • Price

The Ninja SP101 Foodi has 8 functionalities: air fry, air roast, air broil, bake, bagel, toast, dehydrate and keep warm.

The large size allows for a 13″ Pizza, up to 9 slices of toast, or 6 chicken breasts (6–8 oz. Each).

One unique feature of the Ninja Oven is its ability to flip up when not in use, using less counter space while storing. However, do be aware the dimensions are more significant than the other toaster ovens discussed here, so be sure and measure.


Comparison Table

Black+DeckerHamilton Beach KitchenAidHomeRussoNinja
5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens - Black and Decker5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens - Hamilton Beach5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens - KitchenAid5 Top Rate Toaster Ovens-HomeRusso5 Top Rated Toaster Ovens - Ninja
ColorBlack & SilverStainless Steel Stainless Steel SilverStainless Steel
Air FryerNoNoNoYesYes
Confection NoNo No YesYes
Functions439248
Heats Up To450°450°450°450°450°
Timer30-minutes60-minutesNot StatedNot Stated2 hours and 12 Hours for Dehydrate Function
AccessoriesBake Pan
Broil Rack
Crumb Tray
Baking Pan
Rack
Crumb Tray
Baking Pan
Grill Rack
Drip and Crumb Tray
Metal Rack
Bake Rack
Rotisserie Fork
Air Fryer Baskets
Tray Handle
Fetch Tool
Crumb Tray
Baking/Drip Tray
Skewer Racks
Oven Glove
Air Fry Basket
Crumb Tray
Wire Rack
Sheet Pan
Capacity Can fit 9″ Pizzas, 4 Slices of Bread, etc.9″ Pizza, muffins, potato, casserole etc.Not stated other than 50% more capacity.15.8 Quarts – 7 lb Whole Chicken, 8 Inch Pizza, 2 lb French Fries, etc.Fits a 13″ Pizza, Up To 9 Slices of Toast or 6 Chicken Breasts (6–8 oz. Each).
Dimensions11.18 x 15.47 x 8.3 inches12.05 x 17.8 x 10.24 inches16 x 17 x 11.3 inches12.32 x 13.54 x 13.35 inches19.72 x 7.56 x 14.96 inches
Flipped Up: 19. 7″ 15. 1”H x 7. 5”D
Weight5 lbs10.9 lbs15.9 lbs15.47 lbs15.72 lbs
ManufacturerBlack+DeckerHamilton BeachKitchenAidHomeRussoSharkNinja
Price PricePricePricePricePrice

If you are interested in an Air Fryer I wrote a buying guide that discusses the features, pros and cons of small air fryers:

I hope in reading, 5 Top Rated Toaster Ovens (2021 Comparison Guide), you were able to narrow down your search for the perfect toaster oven.

If you have any stories or experience with toaster ovens I would love to hear about them. Please comment below.

Leave a Comment